[Shop-talk] GFCI Question

Randall tr3driver at ca.rr.com
Sat Feb 2 17:25:26 MST 2008


> It's worth pointing out that an external tester will not work 
> on a GFCI that's connected to a two-wire circuit.

Sure it will, if you do the current balance test to an external ground (or
even between a protected neutral and an unprotected hot).  Checking the
ground/neutral short detection function should work too.

> That's allowed by code most places,

Legal or not, I don't like the idea of having a safety ground pin that
isn't.  IMO, sooner or later, someone will get killed by this setup and the
NEC will decide it's a bad idea.

I'd rather have no ground pin at all (which I believe is still allowed by
code in old construction tho not for remodel or new installations) than a
fake ground.

They used to allow aluminum wire in homes, too.

Randall


More information about the Shop-talk mailing list